Doctor Didn't Realise Baby Was DISABLED

by Robert Dunne

A mum in Portugal has been left furious at her obstetrician after he failed to acknowledge a number of visible disabilities on her child that could be seen via her ultrasounds.

Parents Marlene Simão and David Ribiero were left stunned after finding out their son, Rodrigo, was severely disabled, as their obstetrician, Dr Artur Carvalho, had repeatedly assured the couple that their son was perfectly normal and healthy. The child was born in Setúbal, 20 miles south of Lisbon, on October 7, with his eyes, nose, and part of his skull missing.

Obstetrician missed that baby was disabled
Parents Marlene Simão and David Ribiero. Photo Credits:Facebook

Before the birth, Carvalho had performed three separate ultrasounds on the baby, and on each occasion had insisted the baby was healthy and no abnormalities were found, however, Marlene decided to have a 5-D Scan under a different doctor, where you can see the individual features of a baby. The results of which, pointed towards the existence of a defect of the baby’s face. In a confrontation with Carvalho regarding this conflicting result, Carvalho attempted to uphold his case by arguing that the scans were inaccurate, and in fact, the baby was perfect.


After the child was born, the family complained to the Portuguese Prosecutors Office, which resulted in a case being opened into Carvalho, which added to the four previous investigations opened by the office about similar cases, including one case in 2011 in which a baby girl was born without a chin, with inverted legs, toes fused together and severe brain injuries. In addition to these cases, there are also another six active disciplinary hearings open in regards to Carvalho, not including Rodrigo’s case, with another five having been closed that date back to 2007.

Despite being told by medics that the infant may not live more than a few hours, two weeks after his birth, baby Rodrigo is still alive and able to breathe independently and is feeding from a bottle. Mother Marlene has refused to leave the newborn’s side since birth, however, the child is, according to medics, losing weight every day, meaning the amount of time the couple get with their son still hangs in the balance.

If you enjoyed reading this article why not share it with others!

Written by

Robert Dunne

Junior Content Writer
Hiya! I’m Rob, a Content Marketing Apprentice from Kent, although my work with Your Baby Club all takes place from London. My main passions are politics, journalism, current affairs and events and generally staying in the present moment. Most of my time is spent out experiencing the world, whether that’s by foot, train or car, seeing and doing all that I can in the world. It is my intention to keep the parents of Britain, as well as those generally interested, informed in all things baby that is happening in the world with the hope of one day becoming a platform of news, knowledge and conversations for all those interested in the world of babies.

Related articles